Parliamentary democracy can no longer really be called democratic today. When it was introduced in 1848, the system was already limited: a property-based franchise applied, under which only 7 to 12 percent of adult men were allowed to vote. Universal male suffrage did not come until 1917, women’s suffrage in 1922, and young people from the age of 16 are still not allowed to vote.
Until about 1960 the system fitted pillarisation: people voted largely on the basis of faith or worldview. After that, citizens became strongly individualised, but the political system did not adapt. Voters can still only choose a complete party package. This leads to eight structural problems:
- The free mandate: Members of Parliament vote without mandate and are not bound by the programme or the promises on which they were elected.
- Group discipline: the elected member is often more accountable to the party leadership than to the voters.
- The package problem: the voter has to swallow a complete package of positions, including positions he or she does not share.
- Coalition politics: not the election result but the coalition formation determines the real course, led by people who are not elected by the people.
- No binding instruments: between elections the citizen cannot steer things; there is no binding referendum.
- A world of its own: many politicians have little experience outside politics, so The Hague is becoming less and less representative.
- Short-term thinking: elections every four years encourage policy that scores quickly, while long-term issues are left unresolved.
- Unequal influence: lobbyists, interest groups and the media have access to power; the ordinary voter does not.
Almost all current political parties use the votes of the voters as it suits them.
The question therefore remains justified: how democratic is our parliamentary democracy still, really, at this moment?





